top of page
  • Writer's pictureBill Raines

Prosecutor files motion to dismiss case against Jeremy Small today in Lawrence County Superior Court

LAWRENCE COUNTY - OCTOBER - 5, 2023 - Lawrence County Prosecutor Samuel Arp II has filed a motion in Lawrence County Superior Court I to dismiss the case against Jeremy Small on his charges of Resisting law enforcement by forcibly to resist or obstruct and failure to identify without prejudice today.

Small was scheduled to go to trial on October 19th at 8:30 a.m. the trial was to last three days. At this time Judge John Plummer III has not ruled on the motion.

Video: Jeremy Small's account of events contradicted in a video released to the Lawrence County Zephyr last week

The case happened on October 6th of last year and the Lawrence County Zephyr has monitored developments in the case.

Last week Lawrence County Zephyr has obtained video that has contradicted Small's statements.

However, many have questioned why Bedford Police did not arrest former IU Health Police Officer B.J. Fulkerson for admittedly reckless driving and his conduct on that day.

BEDFORD - MAY 21, 2023 - Lawrence County Zephyr have been asked to follow the developments in the arrest and trial of a Mitchell man.

Video: YouTube Video of a Mitchell man's arrest and threat of child being taken by the Indiana Department of Child Services have circulated over socail media this week

Jeremy A. Small, Mitchell, Indiana was arrested on October 6, 2022, by Bedford Police Department after a former off duty IU Health Police Officer B.J. Fulkerson made a 911 call to the department.

Small was arrested for resisting law enforcement, by knowing and intentionally to obstruct, and refusal to identify himself to the police officers. There is no record of Small being cited for any traffic violations.

However, during the video of the interaction with Bedford Police Department officers and Small the Bedford Police Department officers could not articulate the reason why Small was being arrested.

Small's young child was in the vehicle at the time of the arrest, and he was threatened that child protective services would take his child. During the threat the Bedford Police Officer did not communicate of why Small was being detained or any traffic violations that were committed during the traffic stop.

Officer B.J. Fulkerson has been recently hired by the Springville Community Academy as a school resource officer.

YouTube video of the body camera footage of the stop, and questions raised by a YouTube Group called Official Misconduct was circulated among social media platforms this week in Lawrence County.

Other YouTube video from the group Official Misconduct have circulated with Bedford Police Department and the Lawrence County Sheriff's Department officials have been circulated on social medial platforms.

Lawrence County Superior Court II Judge Bob Cline found that the Bedford Police officers did have probable cause in the case on October 11, 2022.

Small is being represented by Attorney Justin Tyler Boren, Martinsville, Indiana and a jury trial for Small has been scheduled on October 19, 2023

Lawrence County Zephyr will be following the court case after members of the public requested it.

Lawrence County Zephyr will be researching this story and report further developments on this arrest and trial.

Lawrence County Superior Court Judge John Plummer III will be presiding over the jury trial with Lawrence County Prosecutor Sam Arp II representing the State of Indiana.

For breaking news, news and information go to or the Lawrence County Zephyr Facebook page.


1420 L Street Bedford, Indiana

1416 J Street Bedford, Indiana

1,092 views1 comment

1 Comment

Oct 06, 2023

Thanks Bill for following this case!

bottom of page